Skip to content

Vietnam Combat Vet on Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell and Discrimination

– Federal Judge Finds Act Violates First Amendment Rights of U.S. Service Members

By Ernest A. Canning in the BradBlog

In her Sept. 9 decision [PDF] in Log Cabin Republicans vs. United States, U.S. District Court Judge Virginia A. Phillips, a 1995 Clinton appointee, determined that “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” (D.A.D.T) is unconstitutional as it violates First Amendment rights even within the more restrictive confines of military speech.

The court rejected the government’s argument that Log Cabin Republicans lacked standing to initiate the action, noting that at least one member of the group, John Nicholson, was discharged from the armed forces because of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell.” It expressly found that D.A.D.T “does not significantly further the government’s interest in military readiness or unit cohesion,” and directed plaintiff’s counsel to prepare a “Proposed Judgment, including a Permanent Injunction” by no later than Sept. 16.

Whether the Eric Holder Justice Department will appeal, despite President Obama’s pledge to seek a repeal of D.A.D.T., is an open question…

For the military, D.A.D.T. was a self-inflicted wound

In her decision, Judge Phillips not only pointed to official statistics revealing that some 13,023 members of the U.S. Armed forces had been discharged under D.A.D.T. between 1994 and 2009, but to the testimony of Dr. Lawrence Korb which reflected that D.A.D.T. produces an annual loss of approximately 5,000 via loss of recruiting and decisions not to re-enlist; that, for every service member discharged after ten years of service, six new members must be recruited to recover the lost level of experience.

The court observed:

According to the government’s own data, many of those discharged had education, training, or specialization in so-called ‘critical-skills’ including Arabic, Chinese, Farsi or Korean language fluency; military intelligence; counterterrorism; weapons development; and medicine.

Hypocrisy of D.A.D.T. exposed

The court noted that after 2001 even as the military was enforcing D.A.D.T., it began admitting convicted felons under “morals waivers.” It also pointed to the hypocrisy in the Department of Defense practice to delay discharge proceedings until after the service member completed an overseas combat mission and was redeployed in the U.S. — a delay that “undermined” the government’s claim that D.A.D.T. “served the interests of military readiness and unit cohesion.”

 Breathtaking scope of intrusion into Service Members’ First Amendment Rights

 In a single paragraph, Judge Phillips summed up the scope of D.A.D.T.’s overreach.

Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell infringes on the fundamental rights of U.S. services members…The Act denies homosexuals serving in the Armed Forces the right to enjoy ‘intimate conduct’ in their personal relationships….the right to speak about their loved ones while serving their country in uniform; it punishes them with discharge for writing a personal letter…to a person of the same sex with whom they shared an intimate relationship before entering the military service…for including information in a personal communication from which an unauthorized reader might discern their homosexuality

Fundamentally different rationale used here as compared to finding that CA Prop 8 same-sex marriage ban unconstitutional

It is important to avoid reading too much into this decision.

 Judge Vaughn Walker’s Aug. 4, 2010 decision, which found California’s ban on same-sex marriage to be unconstitutional, was decided on Equal Protection grounds. In this case, Judge Phillips’ decision reflects that she previously dismissed an Equal Protection argument presented by the Log Cabin Republicans.

Thus, this case does not stand for the proposition that exclusion of homosexuals from military service is unconstitutional. It merely establishes that if homosexuals are to be permitted to serve, a statute which permits them to be discharged because the content of their speech reveals their homosexuality violates the First Amendment.

Ball is in Eric Holder’s Court

 Once the court issues its injunction, the Justice Department has a right to appeal. If it allows the decision to become final without an appeal, the D.A.D.T. will be swept into the dustbin of history. If the Justice Department files an appeal, it would likely seek a stay of Judge Phillips’ ruling pending the outcome of the appeal.

 Given the President’s promise to seek a repeal of D.A.D.T., a challenge to this well-reasoned opinion would make no sense politically, economically or morally. But then, given the Department’s track record in such matters as defending the abhorrent state secrets doctrine and extraordinary rendition, nothing it did at this point with respect to D.A.D.T. would shock me.

 * * *

 Ernest A. Canning has been an active member of the California state bar since 1977. Mr. Canning has received both undergraduate and graduate degrees in political science as well as a juris doctor. He is also a Vietnam vet (4th Infantry, Central Highlands 1968).

View the original article at Veterans Today

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Posted in Freedom of Speech.

Tagged with , , , , , , .

0 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.

Support #altnews & keep Dark Politricks alive

Remember I told you over 5 years ago that they would be trying to shut down sites and YouTube channels that are not promoting the "Official" view. Well it's all happening now big time. Peoples Channels get no money from YouTube any more and Google is being fishy with their AdSense giving money for some clicks but not others. The time is here, it's not "Obama's Internet Cut Off Switch" it's "Trumps Sell Everyones Internet Dirty Laundry Garage Sale". This site must be on some list at GCHQ/NSA as my AdSense revenue which I rely on has gone down by a third. Either people are not helping out by visiting sponsors sanymore or I am being blackballed like many YouTube sites.

It's not just Google/YouTube defunding altenative chanels (mine was shut), but Facebook is also removing content, shutting pages, profiles and groups and removing funds from #altnews that way as well. I was recently kicked off FB and had a page "unpublished" with no reason given. If you don't know already all Facebooks Private Messages and Secret Groups are still analysed and checked for words related to drugs, sex, war etc against their own TOS. Personally I know there are undercover Irish police moving from group to group cloning peoples accounts and getting people booted. Worse than that I know some people in prison now for the content they had on their "secret private group". Use Telegrams secret chat mode to chat on, or if you prefer Wickr. If you really need to, buy a dumb phone with nothing for the NSA/GCHQ to hack into. Ensure it has no GPS tracking on it and that the battery can be removed. These are usually built for old people to get used to technology storing only a set of numbers to call. However they have no games, applications to install or other ways people can exploit the computer tracking device you carry round with you most of the day - your smart phone. If you are paranoid ensure that you can remove the battery when travelling around and do so to prevent GPS tracking or phone mast triangulation. Even with your phone in Flight mode or turned off, it can be turned on remotely and any features like front or back cameras, microphones and keylogging software can be installed to trace you.

So if your not supporting this site already which brings you news from the Left to the Right (really the same war mongering rubbish) then I could REALLY do with some..

Even if it's just £5 or tick the monthly subscription box and throw a few pound my way each month, it will be much appreciated. Read on to find out why.


Any support to keep this site would be appreciated. You could set up a monthly subscription for £2 like some people do or you could pay a one off donation as a gift.
I am not asking you to pay me for other people's articles, this is a clearing house as well as place to put my own views out into the world. I am asking for help to write more articles like my recent false flag gas attack to get WWIII started in Syria, and Trump away from Putin. Hopefully a few missiles won't mean a WikiLeaks release of that infamous video Trump apparently made in a Russian bedroom with Prostitutes. Also please note that this article was written just an hour after the papers came out, and I always come back and update them.

If you want to read JUST my own articles then use the top menu I have written hundreds of articles for this site and I host numerous amounts of material that has seen me the victim of hacks, DOS plus I have been kicked off multiple hosting companies, free blogging sites, and I have even had threats to cease and desist from the US armed forces. Therefore I have to pay for my own server which is NOT cheap. The more people who read these article on this site the more it costs me so some support would be much appreciated.

I have backups of removed reports shown, then taken down after pressure, that show collusion between nations and the media. I have the full redacted 28/29 pages from the 9.11 commission on the site which seems to have been forgotten about as we help Saudi Arabia bomb Yemeni kids hiding in the rubble with white phosphorus, an illegal weaapon. One that the Israeli's even used when they bombed the UN compound in Gaza during Operation Cast Lead. We complain about Syrian troops (US Controlled ISIS) using chemical weapons to kill "beautiful babies". I suppose all those babies we kill in Iraq, Yemen, Somalia and Syria are just not beautiful enough for Trumps beautiful baby ratio. Plus we kill about 100 times as many as ISIS or the Syrian army have managed by a factor of about 1000 to 1.

I also have a backup of the FOX News series that looked into Israeli connections to 9.11. Obviously FOX removed that as soon as AIPAC, ADL and the rest of the Hasbra brigade protested.

I also have a copy of the the original Liberal Democrats Freedom Bill which was quickly and quietly removed from their site once they enacted and replaced with some watered down rubbish instead once they got into power. No change to police tactics, protesting or our unfair extradition treaty with the USA but we did get a stop to being clamped on private land instead of the mny great ideas in the original.

So ANY support to keep this site running would be much appreciated! I don't have much money after leaving my job and it is a choice between shutting the server or selling the domain or paying a lot of money just so I can show this material.

Material like the FSB Bombings that put Putin in power or the Google no 1 spot when you search for protecting yourself from UK Police with "how to give a no comment interview". If you see any adverts that interest you then please visit them as it helps me without you even needing to give me any money. A few clicks per visit is all it takes to help keep the servers running and tag any tweets with alternative news from the mainstream with the #altnews hashtag I created to keep it alive!

However if you don't want to use the very obvious and cost free ways (to you) to help the site and keep me writing for it then please consider making a small donation. Especially if you have a few quid sitting in your PayPal account doing nothing useful. Why not do a monthly subscription for less money instead. Will you really notice £5 a month?