Mahmoud Abbas submits a formal letter of application to Ban Ki-moon, asking for full Palestinian membership of the UN. Photograph: Shen Hong/Xinhua Press/Corbis

Let Palestine be Palestine


by U.S. Ambassador Charles Cecil


Just think for a minutewhat would happen if the United States abstained when the Palestinian question comes before the UN Security Council ?

Ed Note / Debbie Menon: Yes. President Obama is facing another Catch-22 issue of his career, which is going to turn into a huge embarrassment for him and every American with “an iota of logic or conscience.” He has failed each and every one he has been confronted with so far.The fact that this is a bit bigger than all of the previous ones, is hardly significant. He has long ago shown the color of his spots….

The only thing left intact it seems is Ambassador Charles Cecis apparent belief in his President after all.

By the end of the week perhaps he will have been shocked to find out just how much of a morally bankrupted leader his President actually is.

I prefer to take the cynical doubter’s position, and be pleasantly surprised if he does the right thing, than to take the blindly hopeful and wishful thinking position, and be proven wrong.

“Say it ain’t so, Joe,” the kid asked. Joe said, “Sorry, kid, it is so!” The kid should never have asked, if he loved Joe!

From: U.S. Ambassador Charles Cecil


Ambassador Charles Cecil, Niger

To President Barack Obama

September 17, 2011

Just think for a minutewhat would happen if the United States abstained when the Palestinian question comes before the UN Security Council in the next week or two?

The resolution would pass. The world would be stunned. The United States would enter an entirely new era in our relations with the Muslim countries of the world. The vision you outlined in Cairo for better relations with the Islamic world would take the largest step forward of your presidency. The United States would once again have regained the high moral ground we so often claim to occupy. The energies loosed by the Arab spring would continue to be devoted to their own domestic affairs rather than being diverted into condemning the United States. We are hypocrites when we claim to want justice for the Palestinians but we do nothing meaningful to help achieve this.

On the other hand, if the United States vetoes the Palestinian request for statehood, we will damage our position in the Islamic worldnot merely the Arab Worldfor untold years to come. We will become the object of retribution throughout the Muslim world, and will give new energy to the lagging efforts of al-Qaida to retaliate against us. I served my country 36 years in the Foreign Service of the United States, ten assignments in ten Muslim countries. I know the power of this issue. Why would we want to give new impetus to anti-American sentiment throughout the Muslim world?

Mr. Netanyahus office has issued a statement saying Peace will be achieved only through direct negotiations with Israel. You know, and I know, that Mr. Netanyahu has no intention of concluding a just and fair peace with the Palestinian Authority. His only concern is to continue the inexorable construction of more settlements, creating more facts on the ground until the idea of an independent Palestinian state becomes a mere memory of a bygone era. When Israel declared its independence in 1948 it did not do so after direct negotiations with Palestine. If Israel really wants to negotiate with the Palestinians, why would negotiating with an independent Palestinian government, on an equal footing, deter it from engaging in these negotiations?

The Reagan administration launched an international information campaign under the slogan Let Poland be Poland. Its time we let Palestine be Palestine.

Abstain from this upcoming vote. Just think about it.

Sincerely yours, Charles O. Cecil U.S. Ambassador, retired
(Ambassador to the Republic of Niger during the Clinton Administration)


Write or Telephone those working for you in Washington. The final vote is not expected to take place for more than a month.

President Barack Obama
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, DC 20500
(202) 456-1414
White House Comment Line: (202) 456-1111
Fax: (202) 456-2461

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton
Department of State
Washington, DC 20520

State Department Public Information Line:(202) 647-6575

Press and Public Diplomacy Section
United States Mission to the United Nations
799 United Nations Plaza
New York, N.Y. 10017
Opinion & Comment line: 212-415-4062
Fax: 212-415-4053

Any Senator
U.S. Senate
Washington, DC 20510
(202) 224-3121

Any Representative
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20515
(202) 225-3121

E-mail Congress and the White House

E-mail Congress: visit the Web site <> for contact information.

E-mail President Obama:
<[email protected]>

E-mail Vice President Joe Biden:
<[email protected]>